6 Best Jelly Roll Pans

6 Best Jelly Roll Pans: For all you baking enthusiasts, this is what you have been looking for!

A jelly roll pan is a baking tin specifically designed for a Swiss roll, also known as a jelly roll. Do not confuse a jelly roll pan with a baking sheet or a cookie sheet.

A Swiss roll requires a thin cake sheet, baked sturdy enough to hold jelly or crème or any other filling inside. A jelly roll pan is just the right pan to get that sturdy yet soft and foldable cake sheet.

You will find these pans easily at the stores, in a variety of materials but the commonly used ones are the aluminum or aluminized steel jelly roll pans.  These pans are designed to make the perfect thin and spongy cake sheets that can easily be rolled up and made into jelly rolls.

Our List Of The Best Jelly Roll Pans

For you to get your perfect home-made jelly roll, we have a list of jelly roll pans to choose from. After extensive research on the variety of jelly roll pans available in the market, considering its features, material, and its rating, here we have for you the perfect list. This should make deciding easier.

USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan

All USA Pans are a commercial grade heavy gauge aluminized steel. The Pans are made from 65% of recycled steel and are oven safe up to 450 degrees

This jelly roll pan is top on our list because it’s made up of aluminized steel, this is a classic jelly roll pan with a cooling rack. This is great for baking jelly rolls, cookies, and vegetables.

Because of its unique corrugated surface, it allows airflow for quick release and evenly baked jelly rolls.

The surface is made of Americoat and a special silicone coating. This makes the removal of the baked rolls and cookies easy because of the perfect nonstick surface.

The cooling rack is special only to this particular pan and makes it different and better than the rest.

This nonstick surface is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA free. These help in easy removal as well as easy cleanup. What more could you ask for?

The dimensions are perfect for a good-sized jelly roll, 14.75x 9.75×1” are the outer pan dimensions. The cooling rack is something that takes this jelly roll pan a few notches higher than the others.

This rack is a little raised and it has a crosswire design on it. This allows easy passage of air and aids in cooling the baked product.

It is also easy to maintain and the silicon coating lasts for years keeping its nonstick ability intact. Durable, strong, yielding high performance. You cannot beat the manufacturing experience here!

Nordic Ware Baker’s Jelly Roll

The next on our list is the Nordic Ware baking sheet. If you are looking for Aluminum baking sheets, then this is the one for you.

It is made up of 100% Aluminum which is why it does not rust easily. Because of the presence of pure Aluminum, the baking dish will last longer and is more durable.

As Aluminum is a great conductor of heat, the rolls, and cookies baked in this pan, rise, and bake evenly.

Pans that are made of a special hardened aluminum alloy that provides superbly uniform heat conductivity and maximizes scratch resistance.

Shiny and non-porous natural aluminum provides a natural nonstick performance.

The presence of reinforced steel rims prevents the jelly roll baking pan from warping. The dimensions of the exterior of the pan are 15.75” in length and 1.63’ in height, 11.25” in width.

Aluminum is reactive to acidic ingredients such as vinegar and tomato products. These foods may darken, pit, or corrode the pan after prolonged use.

Metal utensils and scouring pads may scratch natural aluminum pans.

This pan is easy to clean but one thing that we feel is not quite right is the fact that this pan must be washed manually, you cannot put it in the dishwasher, as it can cause discoloration in the pan because of the washing chemicals.

This is the feature that brings it down in the rung according to our research and the feedback from users.

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan

This nonstick baking pan is made up of Aluminum and steel, which is heavy, so it helps in the even distribution of heat.

This product is at number three on our list, but it has so many advantageous features. The latest technology is used in the making of this product, which makes it something you cannot miss out on.

It is heavy and of good quality, and lasts long if used carefully.

This pan is Swiss engineered and is reinforced with ceramic. The pan has a double coating of Aluminum steel, which makes baking a wonderful experience. It allows heat to be distributed equally.

The non-stick line also features a micro-textured pattern that ensures even baking by minimizing your food’s surface contact with the pan and promoting airflow.

All OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Bakeware pieces feature generous square-rolled edges for reinforcement and a secure grip and are dishwasher safe for easy cleanup.

The surface of the pan is micro-textured; there is no staining, scratching, or even corrosion.

Cleaning is amazingly simple. The square rolled edges give it strength and offer a secure grip while transferring the pan to and from the oven.

The internal dimensions are 8.49x 13.37” simply perfect for a good-sized roll.

The internal size is 10.5 x 9.25″, which is less area obviously. So, your baked goods might come out thicker than you expect if you usually use a 9×13” pan.

Users also complain about the difficulty in cleaning these pans, unlike the ones which are dishwashing safe and easy to clean.

After removing the jelly roll, many people complain of the bottom of the pan turning dark and no amount of scrubbing brings it back to its original color.

Chicago Metallic Pan

This jelly roll pan is the next in our list and is made from Aluminum steel, so it is naturally heavier. This makes heating even and the baked goods come out fresh and airy.

This is suitable for baking cookies, cakes, muffins, and jelly rolls.

The Chicago metallic commercial 11 is a traditionally uncoated large jelly roll pan that comes with a wire rod and reinforced rims on the pans. This prevents the pan from getting scratches or dents or getting warped.

This pan has a traditional design like the simple pans of the older days. This is the one pan that is not coated with anything and that makes it different than other pans.

So, it looks old and classic and adds for a distinct flavor of its own. The dimensions of this pan are 16.75” by 1” by 12”.

It is easily washable and is dishwasher friendly, but it is recommended that to make it last longer you wash it manually.

The old classic and sober look of this pan is what makes it so likable. Its durability makes it in our list of the best jelly pans.

However, something is not quite right with the finishing of the pan. After use, there seems to be some discoloration unlike other pans, which are sturdier and more durable.

These pans also bubble and peel and get ruined in the process. It is not nonstick and is not easy to clean according to reviews. These pans with a different edge design would probably get better reviews.

Wilton Performance Pans

This jelly and cookie pan is a large multipurpose pan that will fulfill all your baking needs.  This is one of the best large jelly roll pans.

It is made of Aluminum and the best feature is that it is so well coated, it evenly heats up. These make beautiful well-baked cookies and even jelly rolls.

The Wilton large-sized sheet cake pan is 12×18” and is all-purpose. It can be used for baking cakes, desserts, casseroles, and cookies.

The Aluminum prevents it from scratches, dents, or getting warped.

With generous dimensions of 10.5″ x 15.5″, it accommodates a large a quantity of cookies, bars, or brownies.

The raised sides also provide the containment needed for making sponge cake and jelly rolls. This aluminum jelly roll pan heats evenly in the oven, producing thorough and proper baking results.

With a non-stick coating, it offers smooth and easy food release as well as quick and convenient cleaning. Browse the Wilton baking product line for even more dessert pan options.

This pan comes in a large size and has raised sides for greater baking versatility. It has a nonstick coating for easy cleaning and food release. The Aluminum in the pan heats and bakes evenly.

There is no discoloring even after years of use. This multipurpose pan is included in our list because of its strength and durability.

GOTHAM STEEL NONSTICK COPPER PAN

The Gotham Steel Nonstick cookie sheets are all that your baking will ever need.

These are truly the nonstick surface pans. You do not have to season these pans before use, just wipe them clean before first use.

They are made of Copper. Ceramic, and Titanium and are added to resist scratches and dents. Heavy aluminum is coated with the Ti-Ceramic surface on the cooking surface, including an inner side.

This copper cookie sheet and roll pan is easy to use, does not need any oil or butter.

Cleaning up is also extremely easy, you just need to wipe with a clean cloth. It is also dishwasher friendly so just pop it in the dishwasher.

The ceramic and titanium finish to this copper pan makes it oven safe, right up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

People who have used these pans complain of the pans getting sticky after use causing difficulty in cleaning, unlike steel-based pans.

How Is A Jelly Roll Pan Different From A Cookie Tray?

Jelly roll pans are specially designed for a jelly roll also known as the swiss roll.  It just needs a flat baking base with even heating to make soft rolls. a cookie tray is similar but it needs a rack so the cookies can be cooled, the air passing through, preventing cookies from becoming hard.

What Size Pan Is A Jelly Roll Pan?

A jelly-roll pan (either 15 ½ by 10 ½ inches or 18 by 12,) has 1-inch-high sides and is perfect for making cake rolls; it can stand-in for a cookie sheet also.  It can also be used as a roasting pan for veggies and more.

Can I Use A Cookie Sheet To Make Swiss Roll?

Jelly roll pans are remarkably like cookie sheets; if you are making cookies, biscuits, anything that bakes on a flat surface, a cookie sheet will work fine for you. But If you want to make jelly rolls make sure your pan has about an inch-high edges, even if you are using a cookie sheet, make sure it has edges.

How Do I Fix My Warped Pan?

A warped pan does not stay properly in the oven tray, it will wobble around and conduct heat poorly. You can repair it by tapping the bulge back into place but there is no guarantee that it won’t bounce back to its warped shape soon.

My New Jelly Roll Pan Warped, Why?

When you put a rim-less sheet pan in the oven, it will expand, making it warp. That loud clang is what happens the instant the metal becomes too hot. It is the sound of something flat turning into something warped and wobbly.

Conclusion

Now that you have gone through our list of the top 6 best jelly roll pans, it must be easier for you to decide which suits you the best.

The mentioned products above are of a prime quality, have several unique features, but out of the six of them, the best jelly roll pan is the USA Pan 1605CR Jelly Roll Baking Pan and Bakeable Nonstick Cooling Rack. When it comes to this jelly roll baking pan, the features and quality of this one are far better than the other four.

All the five above mentioned products are of different types and have special features of their own. Out of the six mentioned jelly roll baking pans, there is only one pan that is made of copper. The rest of the four are made of aluminum or aluminized steel.

Though copper is a good option, aluminum or aluminized steel is even better. When it comes to manufacturing baking pans, aluminized steel is the perfect choice for most of the manufacturers.