Taylor Swift’s Controversial Women’s March

Taylor Swift’s Controversial Women’s March: Taylor Swift might not have made it to the Women’s March — but she did tweet about it. While hordes of women descended on Washington in pink knit hats and righteous indignation, the day after the inauguration of President Donald Trump in the largest single-day protest in U.S. history, self-proclaimed feminist, Swift, was nowhere to be found.

Taylor’s Swift’s women’s march, it appeared, was happening on twitter.

So much love, pride, and respect for those who marched. I’m proud to be a woman today, and every day. #WomensMarch   — Taylor Swift (@taylorswift13

The backlash was swift and scathing. One fan said.

‘As a fan of yours, this is some bulls**t. You do not get to pick and choose when feminism benefits you,’

Another fan replied…

I love you, but I’m disappointed that you didn’t use your platform to voice your support earlier. Your voice is powerful.’

Celebrities who exercise their political muscles will always have to tread a fine line between advocacy and blatant opportunism.

As a collective, they’re capable of provoking a sort of righteous fury: once a shiny black S.U.V. has deposited you directly at the foot of a stairway leading to a private jet, you are suddenly and permanently beyond any sort of compassion.

But we recognize that our resistance finds strength in numbers and that the powerful can lend their big voices and bigger platforms to vital issues.

When Taylor Swift publicly announced she was leaving country music for pop stardom, in anticipation of her 2014 release 1989, she had to navigate this tricky terrain carefully.

Her transformation from southern sweetheart to pop starlet was remarkably successful; she definitely leveled up, becoming one of the biggest female pop stars in the world, and managed to hold on to much of her original fan base, as well as expand her appeal. How did she make it happen?

She Wears High Heels, I Wear Sneakers

It must be said that Taylor Swift has always known how to tell a relatable story. It’s part of what made her such a hugely successful country music sensation because, within American country music, stardom has always been reliant on a strong sense of truth-telling; performances are all about autobiography and intimate confession.

She’s always had to know how to create the illusion of authenticity and she’s not entirely to be blamed for that; audiences don’t want female distance, they want female openness and accessibility.

Her fans want to feel close to her, and Taylor learned early on how to capitalize on that.

Taylor Swift has always employed an incredibly savvy image maintenance strategy.

She’s known for her skill at persona creation, everything she does is rehearsed and meticulous, and if there were a PR Olympics, her marketing team would take home gold.

“Am I shooting from the hip?”

She asked GQ in 2015, after hearing that an unnamed “someone” had described her as calculating.

“Would any of this have happened if I was? In that sense, I do think about things before they happen. But here was someone taking a positive thing — the fact that I think about things and that I care about my work — and trying to make that into an insinuation about my personal life. Highly offensive. You can be accidentally successful for three or four years. Accidents happen. But careers take hard work.”

It’s true: nobody ascends to the level of fame that Taylor Swift possesses, much less stays there for as long as she has, without all the hard, ugly work.

It just doesn’t happen unless you’re ready and willing to be unrestrainedly obsessive about it. But there’s no place for this ambitious business woman in the All American Sweetheart persona she’s built with her music.

Big Reputation, Big Reputation

The feminism she has started to exemplify, particularly in recent years and months, is no different – it’s well-done, pre-packaged, but then again, why wouldn’t it be?

As Rosalind Gill notes, “feminism has a new luminosity in popular culture.”

That is to say, it’s popular. Swift is among those artists who have made feminist practice a big part of their public image on social media platforms like Twitter and Instagram: Swift’s social media support of the women’s march is her using popular feminism to rebrand the same way she’s been doing for years.

It’s an extension of her branded relationship with female friendships and #GirlPower.

Speaking to the pressure placed on Swift to discuss political causes, media scholar Elizabeth Affuso points to Taylor Swift’s social media support for the women’s march, but notes that Swift not actually attending the march reinforced the contradictory nature of such statements with the apolitical brand she had developed.

This particular controversy extends beyond Taylor’s Swift’s women’s march and into a larger conversation about her relationship with feminism, and the role that media and celebrity play in politics.

At a time when popular expressions of feminism are more visible than ever before, something altogether unexpected has happened. Elements of feminism have certainly been absorbed into our political and conventional lives.

But they’ve been converted into a much more individualistic conversation, and then these ‘feminist gestures’, not more than virtue signaling (the action or practice of publicly expressing opinions or sentiments that are supposed to demonstrate one’s good character or the moral correctness, the ‘rightness’ of your stance on an issue), are distributed en masse in media and popular culture as a kind of substitute for feminism itself.

Swift is the brand ambassador for this PR-friendly marketplace feminism, and its fragile agreements, in which choices and statements that are explicitly feminist must be placed in context alongside her carefully controlled persona.

This branded feminism is an invaluable space for celebrity figures like Taylor to discuss issues of gender inequality within their own careers that cannot, at any length, be unlinked from the capitalist systems in which that gender inequality is reinforced.

We can’t underestimate the importance of the visibility of popular feminism, but it often seems to start and end there, as though seeing or purchasing feminism were equivalent to changing actual patriarchal structures and bringing about actual material improvement in the lives of women everywhere.

Marketplace feminism—the process that celebrities, and corporations, and other commercial bodies use the language of freedom in the service of capital—isn’t a Taylor Swift’s women’s march problem, or even a Taylor Swift problem, in so far as isn’t a Beyonce or Lena Dunham or Tina Fey problem.

It’s what would always happen in a society where celebrities have the most cultural capital (that is, social assets that allow upwards movement in a hierarchical society). They’re a value power resource precisely because they can be used to manipulate audiences into connecting with them on an emotional or psychological level.

These forms of feminist celebrity go a long way towards shaping the kinds of feminism that come to publicly circulate and that, to differing degrees, come to receive cultural legitimacy, making the kind of conversation that happens through this channel both critically and politically important, because of how visible it is.

End Game

Taylor inspires a unique level of hatred because she’s so very good at that.

The cleverest celebrities know the best way to win love is to convince would-be fans that they’re friends, confidantes.

As Vox’s Constance Grady put it:

“Swift’s celebrity image has been caught a tug-of-war between intimacy and control, one characterized by two distinct identities: Taylor Swift, nerdy teen and girl next door, who just happens to naturally be able to give voice to your deepest feelings in her songs; and Taylor Swift, micromanaging CEO of a billion-dollar business in whose marquee product is her own public image.”

Both sides are part of her success, but they can’t be united with each other.

And when they clash? Her persona all but collapses.

Perhaps her high gloss mask is finally slipping. Swift’s place on the cover of TIME’s Person of the Year issue was highly contested by those who argued that her general silence is far, far louder than her choice to break that silence by taking her sexual assault case with Mueller to trial.

Indeed, most of the criticism borne by Swift has been for the lack of intersectionality in her feminism, whether through her defensive response to Nicki Minaj’s critique of award shows for failing to represent black artists (Griffiths, 2017) or in her threatening of legal action against Meghan Herning after the PopFront writer (Herning, 2017) publicly called on the artist to condemn white supremacy within her fanbase (Grady, 2017).

She’s also drawn not insignificant criticism for sitting quietly on the sidelines during the 2016 Presidential Election while fellow pop stars like Katy Perry and Lady Gaga campaigned for Hillary Clinton.

After Swift reemerged from her hiatus to promote the release of her album reputation in 2017, The Guardian (2017) published an unsigned editorial arguing Swift’s silence reinforces President Trump’s values, pointing out the inconsistency between her commitment to feminism and her apolitical star image.

Swift’s celebrity has always been all about these types of half measures, wherein small acts that reinforce her feminism ultimately fail to exhibit a turnabout of her larger celebrity brand toward more beneficial feminist causes.

As Dayna Evans at the Gawker put it:

“Swift isn’t here to help women — she’s here to make bank.”

Written By Isabella

Isabella Martinez, your go-to relationship advisor and creator of Life Falcon. I love diving into love, life, and star signs, sharing helpful tips and interesting thoughts with you.

More About Author

Trending Right Now

INFP Careers to Avoid

Top Must-See INFP Careers to Avoid

Top Must-See INFP Careers to Avoid: This personality type holds a royal place among all 16 personality types identified by Myers-Briggs Theory. And here the INFP (4-lettered abbreviation) stands for

Best Tens Machine for Period Pain

Best Tens Machine for Period Pain

Best Tens Machine for Period Pain: Period cramps can leave you feeling sidelined from your daily routine, for some days, every month. They can seriously hinder your productivity. Where a

Best Top-Fill Humidifiers

5 Best Top-Fill Humidifiers

5 Best Top-Fill Humidifiers: Life is the second name of challenges and hardships, the hardships that we face to lead our lives from bad to best and ultimately to perfection.

ESTP - The Entrepreneur Personality Traits

ESTP – The Entrepreneur Personality Traits

ESTP – The Entrepreneur Personality Traits: Do you ever wonder about what’s going on inside Donald Trump’s head? While we may not have all the answers, we can still give

Why Should You Date A Soccer Player?

Why Should You Date A Soccer Player?

Why Should You Date A Soccer Player?: Dating, like everything else in the world, has been evolving towards eccentricity. People now do not feel shy in expressing their interests and

how to let your teacher know he is wrong?

How To Tell Your Teacher When S/He is Wrong?

How To Tell Your Teacher When S/He is Wrong?: Can you tell your teacher shes wrong? Well, just know that there are two beings on the face of the earth,

Top 6 Landscape architecture firms in California

Top 6 Landscape Architecture Firms in California

Top 6 Landscape Architecture Firms in California: Landscape architecture is, often, the forgotten profession of the development industry. “You can’t use up creativity. The more you use, the more you

Commercial Window

Best Commercial Window Cleaning Robot

Best Commercial Window Cleaning Robot: Why don’t you just focus on your business and let the robot do its job? Window cleaning robots are becoming popular commercially. We won’t be

Is MacKeeper An Apple Product

Is MacKeeper An Apple Product?

Is MacKeeper An Apple Product?: So, you randomly fire up your Mac one day and you find yourself suddenly bombarded with distracting popups and notifications telling you your Mac is

Reasons to Date a Softball Player

12 Reasons to Date a Softball Player

12 Reasons to Date a Softball Player: People dating athletes find themselves in relationships filled with growth, passion, and energy. They consider themselves truly lucky to have found people with

Things to avoid saying to a Sagittarius women

What to do when you send a guy your picture, and he doesn’t respond?

What to do when you send a guy your picture, and he doesn’t respond?: When a guy ignores the picture you sent him, the only thing that leaves you with

Financial Advisor Clients Relatioship

What Do Financial Advisor Clients Want?

What Do Financial Advisor Clients Want?: Even to this age, the concept of financial advice and planning remains engulfed by myths and misconceptions. “It is just for the rich”, “It

The Pros And Cons Of Participation Trophies

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Participation Trophies?

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Participation Trophies?: To compete and having the will to succeed or win is something innate in human nature. Competing for survival has been

Goodyear vs Toyo

Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady VS Toyo Celsius

Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady VS Toyo Celsius: The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company was founded in 1898 by Frank Seiberling. It is an American multinational tire manufacturing company based in Akron,

Can You Watch Netflix On A Chromebook?

Can You Watch Netflix On A Chromebook?

Can You Watch Netflix On A Chromebook?: I am sure you have heard of “Netflix and Chill” it is what every Gen-Z has been saying since Netflix became a popular

Top 7 ISFJ Careers to Avoid

Top 7 ISFJ Careers to Avoid

Top 7 ISFJ Careers to Avoid: “ISFJ” stands for Introversion (I), Sensing (S), Feeling (F), and Judgment (J). the abbreviation itself describes how kind and sensitive these people are. If

Would You Rather Questions For Kids

200 Humorous Would you rather Questions For Kids

200 Humorous Would you rather Questions For Kids: In this Covid-19 pandemic that the world is collectively facing right now, we as adults can find productive ways to spend our

Ways to get your ex back when you are living together

11 Reasons why a Scorpio man hides his feelings from you

11 Reasons why a Scorpio man hides his feelings from you: Scorpios are that one star sign that is infamous for their mysterious personalities and actually suffer from quite a

Get A Taurus Man To Commit

How To Get A Taurus Man To Commit?

How To Get A Taurus Man To Commit?: Taurus is an earth sign represented by a bull. Taurus males are known to be very stubborn with a hard exterior and

Top 5 Life Changing ENTP Careers To Avoid

Top 5 Life Changing ENTP Careers To Avoid

Top 5 Life Changing ENTP Careers To Avoid: Steve Jobs once said: “Those who are crazy enough to think they can change the world are the ones that do.” Are